As students prepare for college admissions, one common question families ask is: Should I take both the SAT and ACT?
While both standardized tests are accepted at nearly every college in the U.S., they each have different formats, structures, and advantages.
For some students, taking both may open up strategic options for admissions and scholarships—but it isn’t always necessary.
At College Benefits Research Group (CBRG), we help students determine the right testing path based on their academic profile, target schools, and personal strengths.
In this article, we’ll explore when it’s a smart move to take both tests—and when it might not be worth the extra effort.
SAT vs. ACT: Key Differences and What They Measure
Though they serve the same purpose, the SAT and ACT differ in key ways that can influence performance.
Key differences include:
- Test Length and Timing: The SAT gives more time per question; the ACT is faster-paced.
- Math Content: The SAT includes math with and without a calculator; the ACT allows a calculator on all math questions.
- Science Section: Only the ACT includes a dedicated science reasoning section.
- Scoring: The SAT is scored out of 1600 (Math + Evidence-Based Reading & Writing), while the ACT is scored out of 36 (average of four sections).
Understanding these distinctions is crucial in identifying which test better suits your learning style.
Do Colleges Prefer One Test Over the Other?
A common myth is that some colleges prefer the SAT over the ACT or vice versa. In reality, nearly all U.S. colleges accept both tests equally, including Ivy League schools, top public universities, and liberal arts colleges.
Additionally, many schools have adopted test-optional or test-blind policies in recent years, which means they may not require standardized test scores at all.
However, strong SAT or ACT scores can still be a valuable asset for:
- Strengthening your application
- Qualifying for merit-based scholarships
- Meeting NCAA eligibility requirements for student-athletes
Colleges want to see your best score—regardless of the test.
Advantages of Taking Both the SAT and ACT
There are several reasons students may benefit from sitting for both the SAT and the ACT.
Here’s why taking both can be beneficial:
- Test Comparison: By trying both, students can identify which test plays to their strengths and submit the better score.
- Superscoring Opportunities: Some schools allow you to combine your best section scores across test dates—even across SAT and ACT in rare cases.
- More Scholarship Options: Some private scholarships require or prefer one test over the other.
- Test Day Safety Net: If one test doesn’t go well, you still have a second set of results.
CBRG often recommends this approach to students aiming for competitive schools or major scholarships, especially if they perform differently in math vs. reading.
When Taking Both Tests May Not Be Worth It
While there are advantages to taking both tests, it’s not the right strategy for everyone.
Taking both tests may not be necessary if:
- Your initial test scores are strong and aligned with your college goals.
- Test prep time is limited, and splitting focus between two formats could dilute results.
- You qualify for free in-school SAT or ACT testing, reducing the need for both.
- You’re targeting test-optional schools, where additional scores won’t significantly impact your application.
Instead of testing more, students may benefit more from improving other parts of their application—like essays, grades, or extracurriculars.
Strategic Testing Plans for Different Student Types
Every student’s path is different. Here’s how CBRG helps different types of students think strategically about the SAT and ACT.
Competitive Applicants:
- May take both tests to strengthen their profile or demonstrate consistency.
- CBRG assists with prep timelines, score reporting strategies, and retesting decisions.
Scholarship Seekers:
- Some scholarship programs are test score-based (e.g., National Merit, state merit aid).
- Students with strong scores in one area may benefit from trying both to open more aid opportunities.
Test-Optional Applicants:
- CBRG helps assess whether test scores will strengthen or weaken an application.
- If submitting scores, we help select the test that presents the best profile.
Student-Athletes:
- NCAA requires test scores for eligibility (depending on division and GPA).
- CBRG coordinates testing and recruiting timelines to meet requirements.
Our advisors work closely with families to create test strategies aligned with admissions deadlines and college-specific requirements.
How CBRG Helps Students Maximize Testing Strategy
Choosing between the SAT and ACT—or deciding to take both—isn’t just about testing. It’s about integrating test scores into a holistic college admissions plan.
CBRG provides:
- Academic assessments to determine which test aligns best with your strengths
- Test timeline planning based on college application schedules
- Recommendations for prep programs and study resources
- Assistance interpreting score reports and setting realistic score goals
- Guidance on whether to retest or submit existing scores
Strategic Testing Success Story
A CBRG student took the SAT and scored well in reading/writing but underperformed in math. They also sat for the ACT and scored significantly higher on the math and science sections. With both scores, the student was able to demonstrate balanced academic strength and was admitted to their top-choice college with a merit scholarship award that required strong ACT scores.
This type of strategic planning can make a real difference in outcomes.
Frequently Asked Questions About SAT and ACT Strategy
Yes. Nearly every college in the U.S. accepts either test equally.
Yes. You are not required to submit all test scores unless a college specifically requests it.
Superscoring is when a college combines your highest section scores across test dates. Many colleges do this for the SAT; some do it for the ACT.
Yes. You can cancel SAT scores shortly after testing. ACT allows you to choose which scores to send to colleges.
You can take the SAT and ACT multiple times, though most students test 2–3 times. Score improvements typically level off after the third attempt.
No. Ivy League schools accept both tests equally. What matters more is submitting your strongest score.
Sometimes. Some scholarships or state programs accept only one test or may have a preference. Submitting the better score increases your eligibility.
Why Your Testing Strategy Should Fit Your Overall College Plan
Standardized tests are just one piece of the college admissions puzzle. Deciding whether to take both the SAT and ACT depends on your goals, timeline, financial aid needs, and academic strengths.
CBRG helps students and families take a strategic, data-driven approach to testing—so scores work in your favor, not against you. If you’re unsure how to approach standardized testing or how your scores fit into your broader application, we’re here to help build the right plan for your college future.